Dr.Dawg

The futility of prison

| Disqus Comments


prison bars2.jpg

The national debate sparked by the Harper government’s “tough on crime” nonsense* hasn’t addressed a basic question: why have we been jailing so many people in the first place? Let me hasten to answer my own query in the case of violent, dangerous criminals—it’s because we’re afraid of them, and we want them kept far away from us as possible, under close supervision. No problem there: rehabilitation of such people is a concept about which I, for one, remain sceptical.

But consider the case of Phillip Shaqu.

Shaqu is a 50-year-old homeless Inuk man in Ottawa with a hearing disability and a problem with alcohol. Having had a few, he refused to leave a homeless shelter, and kicked and shoved police officers trying to remove him. He got the worst of it—a gash on his forehead requiring nine stitches.

He pleaded guilty to assault, resisting arrest and causing a disturbance.

The judge noted that Shaqu, originally from Iqaluit, used to stay outside the house as a child until his mother passed out, to avoid being abused.

Shaqu received his first criminal conviction in 1981 in Iqaluit and has been in and out of trouble with the law ever since, [his lawyer Paul] Lewandowski said. He struggles to communicate, Lewandowski added, which became apparent when Shaqu tried to address the judge in stilted English.

Shaqu was given 42 days of credit for the time he had already spent in jail.

He reportedly “strained to hear” as the judge sentenced him to a further eight days behind bars.

Can anyone explain to me what conceivable social purpose is achieved by jailing this man, with his personal history and a problem now recognized as an illness, after a trial in a language he barely understands?


* $5 billion worth of new prisons to house unreported criminals, and mandatory minimum sentences so that rascally Liberal-appointed judges won’t coddle the decreasing number of criminals actually brought to justice.

Return to the home page

blog comments powered by Disqus

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Dr.Dawg published on February 25, 2011 11:18 AM.

Orindatus Simon Bolivar Wall was the previous entry in this blog.

Humane limits on free speech is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Powered by Movable Type 5.2